Home Loan Loyalty Tax in Australia (2026): How to Check and Fix It

Home loan loyalty tax in Australia: how to check whether you pay more than a new customer and how to fix it with a reprice or a refinance. Everstone Finance, former bankers.
Refinancing · Loyalty Tax

Home Loan Loyalty Tax in Australia (2026): How to Check and Fix It

A loyalty tax is the gap between the rate you pay as an existing borrower and the lower rate the same lender offers new customers. Compare your rate with your lender’s current new customer rate for the same loan. If yours is higher, ask for a reprice; if the lender will not match it, refinance. Everstone Finance arranges both.

The short version (read 17 November 2026)
  • The ACCC measured the gap by loan age: in September 2020, variable owner occupier loans three to five years old cost about 58 basis points (0.58 of a percentage point) more than the average new loan, fixed and variable, across lenders, and loans over ten years old about 104 (final report, 5 December 2020).
  • The Reserve Bank’s latest averages: 6.23 per cent on outstanding variable owner occupier loans against 6.22 per cent on new ones in September 2026, a gap of 0.01 of a percentage point. Both predate the cash rate rises effective 30 September and 4 November 2026, so read the gap, not the level. Averages hide individual loans.
  • The three-step check: your rate, your lender’s new customer rate for the same loan, the difference in dollars a year.
  • A reprice: your lender lowers the rate on the loan you hold. The lender decides.
  • When refinancing wins: when the reprice still leaves a gap that repays the switching costs.

Not sure what your lender offers new customers today? Ahmed, a former banker, checks it against your statement.

Send your rate, balance and a rough property value. He puts the gap in dollars a year and says whether a reprice or a refinance closes it.

Book a loyalty tax check
Free check · Phone or video from any state

What is the loyalty tax on a home loan?

The loyalty tax on a home loan is the extra interest you pay when your rate is higher than the rate your own lender gives a new customer for the same loan. It is not a government tax. An ACCC report published in April 2020 said loyalty can cost existing customers.

Why do existing borrowers pay more than new customers?

Existing borrowers can pay more than new customers because lenders compete for new loans with bigger discounts than older loans were given. The ACCC found the big four banks had given new customers larger discounts over time, while a discount is generally fixed for the life of a loan.

Lenders call new lending the front book and existing loans the back book. The ACCC found those banks sometimes cut the price on an existing loan and mainly did so when the customer asked, so asking comes first. Our guide to refinancing a home loan in Australia sets out the full refinance process.

How big is the loyalty tax in Australia?

On older variable loans the ACCC found gaps of 58 to 104 basis points (hundredths of a percentage point) against the average new loan in September 2020; the Reserve Bank’s all-ages averages for September 2026, the latest published, show almost none. It depends on your loan’s age and the year.

Published figures read 17 November 2026; not any lender’s rate.
SourceDateExisting loans against new
ACCC final reportSeptember 202058 basis points at three to five years old, 71 at five to ten, 104 over ten (variable owner occupier loans across lenders, against the average new loan, fixed and variable)
Reserve Bank Table F6September 20200.30 of a percentage point (3.20 against 2.90 per cent)
Reserve Bank Table F6October 2022 (widest month in the series, which starts in July 2019)0.51 of a percentage point (5.09 against 4.58 per cent)
Reserve Bank Table F6September 20260.01 of a percentage point (6.23 against 6.22 per cent)

The ACCC said a borrower owing $250,000 at 58 basis points above the new loan average could save over $1,400 of interest in the first year by switching.

The Reserve Bank rows are averages across loans of every age at the larger lenders, and the Bank calls them indicative. September 2026 is the latest month published and predates the cash rate rises effective 30 September and 4 November 2026, so a rate on a statement today sits above these levels; the gap between the two figures is the point. An average is made of loans above it and loans below it, so it cannot say where your loan sits; the check below can.

How do I check whether I am paying a loyalty tax?

To check for a loyalty tax, compare two rates from the same lender: yours, and the one it offers a new customer for the same loan.

  1. Find your current rate. It is on your latest statement or in your lender’s app. Note the balance, purpose, repayment type and whether the rate is variable or fixed.
  2. Find your own lender’s new customer rate. On its website, look up the same loan type at your loan to value band (what you owe divided by the property’s value), not the cheapest loan advertised. Use the interest rate, not the comparison rate, and the nearest current product if yours is no longer sold.
  3. Compare, then work out the dollars. Subtract one rate from the other, multiply by your balance and divide by 100. If your rate is the higher one, the answer is your loyalty tax for a year.

One caution: in 2020 the ACCC found the big four banks’ advertised rates were often not what borrowers paid, because many received further discounts, so the real gap may be wider than advertised rates show.

Found a gap in step three? Have it priced before you ring your bank.

Bring both rates and what you owe. Everstone Finance works out the figure worth asking for, takes the request to your lender and sets its reply beside what other lenders are pricing for a loan like yours.

Put a figure on my gap
No cost to you · The lender decides

What does a loyalty tax cost in dollars?

A loyalty tax costs the rate gap multiplied by your balance, every year: $2,000 a year on $500,000 at a gap of 0.40 of a percentage point. This is our own illustration, tied to no lender and no actual rate.

Suppose you owe $500,000 and your rate is 0.40 of a percentage point above your lender’s new customer rate. $500,000 × 0.40 ÷ 100 = $2,000 of extra interest a year: $166.67 a month, or $6,000 over three years. For scale, the Reserve Bank’s average gap was 0.51 at its widest, in October 2022, and 0.01 in September 2026.

The sum holds the balance still; on a principal and interest loan the balance falls each month, so the true figure is a little lower, and lower again on a loan with few years left to run.

How do I ask my lender for a reprice?

To ask for a reprice, contact your lender, quote the two rates from the check and ask it, in writing, to match the new customer rate.

What to say. Moneysmart’s guidance is to tell your lender you plan to switch to a cheaper loan elsewhere, because it may reduce your rate to keep your business.

What strengthens the request. Equity of at least 20 per cent and a good credit score help, Moneysmart says.

How long it takes. Usually days, in our experience, where a refinance takes weeks. The lender may decline or close only part of the gap. Everstone Finance can put the request for you and set the reply beside what other lenders are pricing; our guide to refinancing with the same bank or switching goes through that conversation step by step.

When should I refinance instead of accepting a reprice?

Refinance when your lender’s best answer still leaves a gap that repays the cost of switching.

  • The reprice falls short. The ACCC found some big four bank offers to customers who asked were smaller than the discounts on new loans.
  • Your loan to value ratio has improved. A refinance is assessed on a new valuation, so a lower ratio can put the loan in a cheaper pricing band. Reserve Bank averages for new owner occupier loans in September 2026, before the two latest cash rate rises: 6.20 per cent under 81 per cent of value and 6.34 per cent at 81 or above, a difference of 0.14 of a percentage point.
  • You need a feature your loan lacks, such as an offset account.
  • The break-even works. Switching costs divided by the monthly saving gives the months to repay the move; our refinance savings calculator works out the saving.

Among the costs Moneysmart lists: discharge and application fees, a break fee on a fixed rate, and possibly lenders mortgage insurance under 20 per cent equity. See the cost of refinancing a home loan and when to refinance your home loan.

How does Everstone Finance run the loyalty tax check?

Everstone Finance asks your current lender first, then compares its answer with other lenders, free. One statement is enough to start.

  1. The reprice request. We put it to your lender.
  2. The comparison. That answer goes beside what more than 40 lenders are pricing for a loan like yours, with switching costs and the break-even month.
  3. Your decision. Keep the repriced loan, or refinance and we run the application, discharge and settlement.

Everstone Finance is paid by the lender on settlement, not by you, and every price and credit decision is the lender’s. See our home loan health check for what the review covers and our guide to choosing a mortgage broker to refinance.

Frequently asked questions

Is my bank charging me a loyalty tax on my home loan and how do I fix it?

You are paying one if your rate is above the rate your own lender offers new customers for the same loan type and loan to value band. Check both numbers, then ask your lender to reprice your loan to the new customer rate. If it will not match, refinance where the saving repays the switching costs.

What does loyalty tax mean?

Loyalty tax is the name for the gap between the interest rate an existing borrower pays and the lower rate the same lender offers new customers for the same loan. It is not a government tax. It arises because lenders discount to win new loans while the discount on an older loan usually stays as it was written.

How much is the loyalty tax on a home loan?

In September 2020 the ACCC found variable loans three to five years old paid about 58 basis points above the average new loan, and loans over ten years old about 104. Reserve Bank averages for September 2026, before two further cash rate rises, show almost no gap: 6.23 per cent on outstanding variable owner occupier loans against 6.22 on new.

Will my bank lower my rate if I ask?

It may, but no lender has to. A reprice request asks your lender to lower the rate on the loan you already hold, and the lender decides whether to agree and by how much. Moneysmart says a lender may reduce your rate to keep your business. If the answer falls short, refinancing with another lender is the alternative.

Is it better to renegotiate or refinance?

Renegotiate first, because a reprice keeps your loan in place and avoids switching costs. Refinance when the best rate your lender offers still leaves a gap, when your loan to value ratio has improved or when you need features your loan lacks. Divide the switching costs by the monthly saving to see how soon the move repays itself.

How often should I check my home loan rate?

Once a year is a sound habit. In December 2020 the ACCC recommended that lenders be required to prompt borrowers with variable loans three or more years old every year, and Moneysmart says it is worth checking the market from time to time. Everstone Finance runs the comparison on your figures free and is paid by the lender on settlement.

Sources

  • Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Home Loan Price Inquiry interim report (given to the Treasurer on 30 March 2020 and published 27 April 2020; loyalty can cost existing customers: as at 30 September 2019 the big four banks’ customers with new owner occupier principal and interest loans paid on average 26 basis points less than customers with existing loans; the banks had offered new customers larger discounts over time and discounts are generally fixed for the life of the loan; some lenders call new loans the front book and existing loans the back book; the banks mainly reduced prices on existing loans at the customer’s request, and some offers to customers who asked were smaller than the discounts on new loans; headline rates were not what most customers paid), read 17 November 2026: accc.gov.au, interim report
  • Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Home Loan Price Inquiry final report (given to the Treasurer on 25 November 2020 and published 5 December 2020; as at September 2020 variable loans three to five years old paid about 58 basis points above the average rate for new loans, loans five to ten years old about 71 and loans more than ten years old about 104; a borrower with a loan of around $250,000 would save over $1,400 of interest in the first year at a rate 58 basis points lower; recommendations for a yearly prompt to borrowers with variable loans three or more years old, a standard discharge form, a ten business day limit on discharges and continued price monitoring), read 17 November 2026: accc.gov.au, final report
  • Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, media release 255/20 of 5 December 2020, Home loan borrowers missing out on significant savings by not switching (the same findings and recommendations in summary), read 17 November 2026: accc.gov.au, media release 5 December 2020
  • Reserve Bank of Australia, Statistical Table F6, Housing Lending Rates (publication date 6 November 2026; September 2026: outstanding owner occupied variable rate loans at all institutions 6.23 per cent a year and new owner occupied variable rate loans funded in the month 6.22 per cent; September 2020: 3.20 and 2.90 per cent; October 2022: 5.09 and 4.58 per cent; September 2026 new owner occupied loans by loan to valuation ratio at commitment: 6.20 per cent under 81 per cent and 6.34 per cent at 81 per cent and above; weighted averages reported by lenders with $6 billion or more of housing credit, described by the Bank as indicative and likely to be revised), read 17 November 2026: rba.gov.au, statistical tables
  • Reserve Bank of Australia, Lenders’ Interest Rates page (housing and business rates table for September 2026, sourced to APRA and the Reserve Bank, with the link to Table F6), read 17 November 2026: rba.gov.au, lenders’ interest rates
  • Reserve Bank of Australia, cash rate target page (the cash rate target rose by 0.25 of a percentage point effective 30 September 2026 and again effective 4 November 2026, both after the September 2026 averages in Table F6), read 17 November 2026: rba.gov.au, cash rate target
  • Moneysmart (Australian Securities and Investments Commission), Switching home loans (last updated 3 November 2026; it is worth checking the market from time to time; ask your lender for a better deal, since it may reduce your rate to keep your business; at least 20 per cent equity gives more to bargain with and a good credit score helps; lenders mortgage insurance may apply under 20 per cent equity; compare break, discharge, application and switching fees; keep the new loan a similar length), read 17 November 2026: moneysmart.gov.au, switching home loans
  • Worked example: our own arithmetic on an invented balance and an invented gap, tied to no lender and no actual rate. $500,000 multiplied by 0.40 of a percentage point is $2,000 a year, $166.67 a month and $6,000 over three years with the balance held constant.

Figures quoted from the ACCC and the Reserve Bank are market findings and averages, not the rate of any lender. Everstone Finance is not affiliated with, endorsed by or acting on behalf of any lender. Lender pricing changes without notice and every application is assessed by the lender.

Book your loyalty tax check with Ahmed

phone or Zoom · calendar invite sent immediately

Prefer to call, text or WhatsApp? This is Ahmed’s own mobile, no call centre.

Important information

Book an appointment
Book a call back