Mortgage Broker vs Bank in Australia (2026): Which Gets You the Better Home Loan, and How Brokers Are Paid
For most Australian borrowers a mortgage broker gets the better home loan, and it costs nothing extra to find out. Your bank can only sell you its own loans. A broker compares many lenders, more than 40 at Everstone Finance, must by law act in your best interests (since 1 January 2021), and is paid by the lender, with the amount disclosed in writing before you apply.
- The answer: a broker for most borrowers, and for anyone whose income, deposit or structure is anything but plain. Your own bank can suit a small, simple request on a freshly repriced loan.
- The legal line: since 1 January 2021 a broker must act in your best interests. Bank staff must not sell you an unsuitable loan, and nothing requires them to find a better one elsewhere.
- How brokers are paid: by the lender, upfront after settlement plus a smaller trail while the loan runs. On almost every home loan you pay us nothing, and the amounts are shown in writing first.
- The pocket question: commission is broadly similar across the major lenders, so steering you to one bank pays little. A broker is paid when your loan settles, at whichever lender suits your file.
- The numbers: brokers arranged a record 81.6 per cent of new residential home loans in the June 2026 quarter (MFAA); loans three to five years old paid around 58 basis points more than new ones (ACCC, 2020).
Weighing your bank’s offer against a broker? Put both on the same page, with a former banker.
Send the lender, the rate and the balance, or the loan you have been quoted. You get the same loan priced across our panel of more than 40 lenders, how we are paid on your loan put in writing first, and a plain view of where your own bank sits.
Compare my bank against the market with a former bankerShould you use a mortgage broker or go straight to your bank?
The mortgage broker vs bank question starts with what each one can do. A bank lending manager, however good, can only recommend that bank’s loans, priced the way that bank prices them that week and assessed by that bank’s credit team under that bank’s rules. A broker starts a step earlier: which lenders would approve this file at all, which of those would price it best, and how to structure it so the next move, a refinance, an investment property, a renovation, is easier rather than harder. That is the whole difference, and everything else on this page follows from it.
So the honest answer has two halves. Going straight to your own bank is reasonable when the request is small and simple, the loan has just been repriced so you know the rate is sharp, and nothing about your income or the property is unusual. Even then a broker’s review costs nothing and takes one phone call, so the choice is rarely between a broker and your bank; it is between seeing one lender’s answer and seeing the market’s answer with your bank’s offer sitting inside it. A broker wins outright when the loan has not been repriced in a year or two, when your income is anything other than one salary with payslips, when you are borrowing close to the limit, or when you are buying through a company, trust or self managed super fund.
What a broker cannot do is make a lender say yes. Nothing on this page is a promise of approval or of a rate; it is a description of how the odds and the pricing change when more than one lender is asked.
The four differences that decide it
Strip away the marketing on both sides and four things separate a broker from a branch.
1. Choice of lenders
Your bank sells its own loans: a basic variable, a packaged loan, a fixed rate or two. At Everstone we compare more than 40 lenders: the major banks, the smaller banks, the mutuals and the non bank lenders with no branches to pay for. The right lender for a self employed buyer, an investor with four properties or an Australian paid in another currency is a different lender each time, and your bank is only ever one of them.
2. Your file assessed against many credit appetites, before it is lodged
Every lender has its own appetite: how it counts bonus income, treats a probation period, reads rental income and values a property type. A branch assesses you against one appetite. A broker reads your file against all of them first and lodges it where it fits. Having sat on a bank’s credit desk, Ahmed knows what each question on the form is really asking. That is often the difference between a decline and a first time approval, with one credit enquiry on your record rather than three.
3. Pricing requests and discretionary discounts
The rate a lender advertises is not the rate most borrowers pay. Lenders give discretionary discounts loan by loan, and the size depends partly on who is asking. A branch can ask its own pricing desk about its own loan. A broker lodges a pricing request with each shortlisted lender and compares the written offers, so each lender prices knowing the loan can go elsewhere. We print no discount figures because they move weekly; the number that matters is the one in writing for your file.
4. Time and paperwork
Direct, you fill in the application, gather the documents, chase the valuation, answer the credit team’s questions and, on a refinance, organise the discharge yourself. Through a broker, that is the broker’s job: we prepare and lodge the application, manage the valuation and the lender’s questions, and run the discharge to settlement. Because trail commission is paid while the loan stays open, the job does not end at settlement: next year’s rate review is part of the same relationship.
How mortgage brokers are paid, in plain words
This is the part of the broker or bank question most people have never had explained, so here it is without the jargon. When your loan settles, the lender pays your broker an upfront commission, calculated on the loan amount drawn down. While the loan stays open, the lender pays a smaller trail commission, usually monthly, which stops the day the loan is repaid or refinanced away. Moneysmart, the government’s money guidance service, describes it the same way: lenders generally pay the commission, so you do not pay the broker directly, and brokers must give you information about the commission they may receive.
Three things follow. First, the lender pays, not you. The commission comes out of the lender’s own margin, your interest rate is not loaded to cover it, and lenders price loans the same whether you come direct or through a broker. Moneysmart notes that some brokers do charge a fee directly; any such fee must be set out in a written quote you sign before work starts. For almost every residential home loan you pay us nothing; a fee can apply only in specialist cases such as commercial or asset finance, specialist lending and bridging, and it is disclosed in writing before you apply. Second, the amounts are disclosed to you in writing before you apply, loan by loan, so you can see what each recommended loan would pay us. Third, clawback: if a loan is repaid or refinanced within two years, the lender can take some or all of the upfront commission back from the broker. On a regulated home loan the credit regulations do not allow that cost to be charged to you (regulation 28VG, National Consumer Credit Protection Regulations 2010).
The Best Interests Duty, and what a bank’s own staff owe you
Since 1 January 2021 a mortgage broker in Australia has been required by law to act in your best interests when recommending a loan. The duty sits in Part 3-5A of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009, it was a recommendation of the banking Royal Commission, and ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 273 sets out how the regulator judges whether a broker has met it. Alongside the duty is the conflict priority rule: where the broker’s interests, or a lender’s, conflict with yours, the broker must give priority to yours and must not put the interests of the lender or any third party first. ASIC’s guide expects a broker to present more than one option in most cases, to be able to show why the recommended loan is in your interests, and to keep the records that prove it.
A bank’s own lending staff do not carry that duty. They are bound by the responsible lending rules, which stop a lender putting you into a loan that is unsuitable for you, and by nothing that requires them to tell you a better loan exists down the road. That is not a criticism of the people; it is the shape of the job. A lending manager is employed to sell that bank’s loans and would be acting outside the role by sending you to a competitor.
Two honest limits: the duty covers the credit assistance a broker gives on regulated consumer credit and is not a promise of approval, and a duty is only as good as the records behind it, which is why the written comparison we give you before you apply matters: it is the record that the recommendation was built on your interests.
Are mortgage brokers in the banks’ pocket?
It is a fair question, and it deserves a straight answer rather than a defensive one.
I’ve sat on both sides of the desk.
What it gets right. Brokers are paid by lenders, not by borrowers, and a broker earns nothing unless a loan settles. Before 2021 there was no legal duty on a broker to put your interests first, and the Royal Commission found enough in the industry to recommend one. None of that is invented, and a broker who bristles at the question is answering it.
What it gets wrong. The commission a broker earns is broadly similar across the major lenders, so steering you to a particular bank pays little. Since 2021 the law has required the broker to act in your best interests and to put your interests ahead of any lender’s, with ASIC able to act when that is breached. And the one party in this picture that can only ever recommend a single bank’s loans is the bank itself. If the concern is that advice follows the money, the branch is the structure where that is true by design, not the broker who is paid about the same whichever major lender wins your file.
Our answer, specifically. Everstone Finance was founded by two former bank lenders who left the banks to put what they knew on the customer’s side of the table. We are paid only when your loan settles, we show you the commission on each recommended loan in writing first, and the panel runs to more than 40 lenders because the right one for your file is rarely the obvious one.
Three questions to ask any broker, with our answers
Moneysmart publishes a list of questions to put to a broker before you proceed. Here is the one that matters most for this question, plus two of our own, with Everstone’s answer beside each so you can hold us to them.
- How are you paid, and does it differ between lenders? Ours: by the lender, upfront and trail, after settlement. The figures for each recommended loan are in your written disclosure before you apply, and they sit in a narrow band across the major lenders. You pay us nothing on a home loan.
- If I refinance within two years, can the clawback be charged to me? Ours: no. The credit regulations do not allow it on a regulated home loan.
- Are you owned by a bank or aligned with any specific lender? Ours: we work with banks; we do not work for them. Everstone Finance is founded and run by two former bank lenders and is not tied to any single lender.
For the full set, how to choose the best mortgage broker to refinance your home loan gives you seven tests to run on any broker, including us.
Broker or bank, side by side
| What decides it | Your bank | A broker |
|---|---|---|
| Lenders considered | Its own loans only | More than 40 at Everstone |
| Who reads your file | One credit team | Matched to a lender first |
| Pricing | Its own rate and discount | Written offers, side by side |
| Legal duty to you | Loan must not be unsuitable | Must act in your best interests |
| What you pay | Nothing | Nothing on a home loan |
| Paperwork | You run it | We run it |
| After settlement | You ask for a review | We review your rate |
Already have a home loan? Start with the rate you pay today.
A former banker reads your statement, lodges a repricing request with your current lender, prices the loan across the panel and sets the switching costs against the saving, in writing, so the broker or bank question is answered on your own numbers.
Review my rate with a former bankerRefinancing: where the broker case is strongest
If you already have a home loan, this is the section to act on. The ACCC’s Home Loan Price Inquiry, in its final report of December 2020, found that as at September 2020 borrowers whose loans were three to five years old were paying on average around 58 basis points more than the average rate on new loans, and borrowers five to ten years in were paying around 71 basis points more. The report’s own worked example put the first year saving on a $250,000 loan at more than $1,400 from closing a 58 basis point gap, and more than $2,800 on a $500,000 loan. The pattern it describes, new customers priced sharply and existing customers left where they are, is how lenders have competed for years, and the remedy is the same now as it was then: have the loan repriced or moved.
Refinancing pays when the rate gap on your balance outruns the switching costs, and the arithmetic is simple. The switching costs are the discharge fee from the old lender, government registration fees, any fixed rate break cost and any application fee at the new lender; against them sits the rate gap on your balance, year after year. A broker runs that calculation across the panel, asks your current lender to reprice first, which sets the floor the new lender has to beat, and then runs the discharge and the settlement. Our refinance guide sets out the rates, costs and timing in full.
How Everstone runs the broker or bank question for you
You send us three things: the lender you bank with, the rate you pay or the loan you are considering, and a rough picture of your income and the property. Within the first conversation you know how your file reads to the lenders that matter for it and what the same loan is priced at across the panel. Your own bank’s offer goes into the same comparison, so you see it against the market rather than on its own. From there we lodge a pricing request where your file fits best, prepare and run the application, and keep the loan under review after it settles. Everstone’s co-founders, Ahmed Lotfi and Zappelin Heng, spent more than a decade between them inside Australia’s major banks, which is why the credit desk’s questions get answered before they are asked. The lender pays us on settlement, so the comparison, the advice and the process cost you nothing, and you decide at every step. None of it needs a branch visit. Our online mortgage broker guide walks through the four steps and what each one needs from you. The guide to what a mortgage broker costs goes through the commission and the disclosure line by line, and the About page tells you who we are.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to use a mortgage broker or go directly to the bank?
For most borrowers, a broker. A bank can only recommend its own loans, while a broker compares your file across many lenders and must act in your best interests by law. Your own bank can be fine for a small, simple request on a freshly repriced loan. Neither path is a promise of approval.
Are mortgage brokers in the pocket of the banks?
Brokers are paid by lenders, but the commission is broadly similar across the major lenders, it is disclosed in writing before you apply, and since 1 January 2021 brokers must act in your best interests ahead of any lender. A bank branch can only ever recommend one bank. Everstone Finance is not tied to any single lender.
How do mortgage brokers get paid in Australia?
The lender pays the broker an upfront commission at settlement and a smaller trail commission while the loan runs, both disclosed in writing first. If the loan is repaid within two years the lender can take back some or all of the upfront commission from the broker, and on a regulated home loan the credit regulations do not allow that cost to be charged to you.
Does using a mortgage broker cost more than going to the bank?
No. Lenders price loans the same direct or through a broker, the lender pays the broker on settlement, and on almost every residential home loan at Everstone there is no fee to you. Fees can apply in specialist lending such as commercial or bridging finance, set out in a written quote you sign first.
Do mortgage brokers get better rates than banks?
Often, for two reasons: a broker can lodge a pricing request with several lenders at once and compare the written offers, and the discretionary discount a lender gives depends partly on knowing the loan could go elsewhere. No broker can promise a rate or an approval; ask to see the comparison in writing before you choose.
Should I use a mortgage broker to refinance my home loan?
Yes, in almost every case. The ACCC found in 2020 that borrowers three to five years into a loan were paying on average around 58 basis points more than new borrowers, and a broker works to close that gap by asking your current lender to reprice and pricing the loan across the panel.
Sources
- Australian Securities and Investments Commission, Regulatory Guide 273 Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty, issued 24 June 2020 (RG 273.4: the obligations apply from 1 January 2021; RG 273.9: the conflict priority rule in sections 158LB and 158LF of the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009; RG 273.20: more than one option in most cases; RG 273.21: records): asic.gov.au and the guide itself, PDF, both read 10 October 2026
- Moneysmart (ASIC), Using a mortgage broker (brokers must act in your best interests; how mortgage brokers get paid, upfront and ongoing commission, direct fees only under a signed written quote; questions to ask; checking a broker on ASIC’s professional registers): moneysmart.gov.au, page last updated 4 September 2026, read 10 October 2026
- Mortgage and Finance Association of Australia, Mortgage broker market share reaches record 81.6% (brokers facilitated 81.6 per cent of new residential home loans in the June 2026 quarter, Cotality data commissioned by the MFAA), 3 September 2026: mfaa.com.au and the media release, PDF, read 10 October 2026
- National Consumer Credit Protection Regulations 2010, compilation of 5 September 2026 (regulation 28VG, clawback requirements: paragraph 28VG(2)(a), an obligation to repay commission must not apply for more than 2 years after credit is first provided; paragraph 28VG(2)(c), the consumer must not be subject to an obligation to pay an amount as a result of that repayment; paragraph 28VB(3)(e) makes meeting those requirements a condition of the commission not being conflicted remuneration): legislation.gov.au, read 10 October 2026
- Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Home loan price inquiry final report, published 5 December 2020 (as at September 2020, borrowers with home loans three to five years old were paying around 58 basis points above the average interest rate for new loans, and five to ten years old around 71 basis points; box 2.1 worked examples: over $1,400 in first year interest on a $250,000 loan and over $2,800 on a $500,000 loan): accc.gov.au, read 10 October 2026
- Everstone Finance, What does a mortgage broker cost (commission, fees in specialist cases, clawback), Online mortgage broker Australia (the four step process), Refinance your home loan (switching costs and timing), The best mortgage broker to refinance your home loan (the seven tests) and About Everstone Finance (founders, panel, memberships), all read 10 October 2026
